Decoding Payday Loans: Is it an Installment Plan or a Revolving Cycle?

WILL T. | March 4, 2024

Navigating the world of payday loans can feel like deciphering a complicated code. One common puzzle? Understanding whether you're signing up for an installment plan or getting caught in a revolving cycle. 

Let's break it down: Installment loans let you borrow a set amount and pay it back in fixed portions over time. On the flip side, revolving credit gives you ongoing access to a pool of funds, which you can dip into whenever you need. Knowing the difference can save you from financial pitfalls.

A chalkboard reading "Loans: Fast, Flexible, Cheap"

What is a Payday Loan?

A payday loan is a short-term, high-cost loan designed to provide quick access to cash for individuals facing immediate financial needs. While there's no universal definition, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) defines payday loans as typically amounting to $500 or less, due on the borrower's next payday. They are commonly offered by storefront payday lenders or online platforms, subject to state regulations.

Unlike traditional loans, payday loans feature a fast approval process, making them appealing to those in urgent need. They're often sought after for covering unexpected expenses or bridging financial gaps between paychecks. 

Here's what sets payday loans apart:

  • Small Loan Amounts: Typically ranging around $500, though limits vary by state.
  • Short-Term Repayment: Payday loans are usually repaid in their entirety on or before the borrower's next payday, usually within two to four weeks.
  • Repayment Methods: Repayment can involve a post-dated check for the full balance, including fees, or authorization for electronic debit from the borrower's account.
  • Limited Consideration of Financial Situation: Lenders typically don't assess the borrower's ability to repay the loan while meeting other financial obligations.
  • Disbursement Options: Loan proceeds may be provided in cash, check, electronically deposited, or loaded onto a prepaid debit card.

These loans offer convenience but can trap borrowers in cycles of debt due to high fees and interest rates. Understanding their terms and alternatives is crucial for making informed financial decisions.

Installment vs. Revolving Loans

Understanding the disparity between installment and revolving loans is essential for borrowers to make informed financial decisions. Installment loans entail borrowing a fixed amount, which is then repaid through predetermined, regular payments over a set period. 

This structured approach ensures clarity and predictability for borrowers. For instance, if you borrow $1,000 as an installment loan with a repayment term of 12 months, you would make monthly payments of around $83.33 (not including interest) until the loan is fully repaid.

On the other hand, revolving credit offers borrowers ongoing access to a line of credit, allowing them to withdraw funds up to a predetermined limit as needed. Unlike installment loans with fixed payments, revolving credit permits more flexibility in repayment amounts and timing. For instance, with a $1,000 revolving credit line, you could borrow $500 initially, repay it, and then borrow another $500, all within the credit limit.

To illustrate, suppose you have a credit card with a $1,000 limit. You use $500 to cover unexpected car repairs, then repay $200 the following month. This leaves you with $300 available credit. Later, you decide to use $300 for a weekend getaway, bringing your balance to $600 plus any accrued, unpaid interest. As you repay, your available credit replenishes, providing ongoing financial flexibility.

Understanding these differences empowers borrowers to select the most suitable option for their financial needs and capabilities.

A notebook reading "Installment Loan"

Payday Loans as Installment Plans

While payday loans are traditionally associated with short-term, single-payment structures, there are instances where they can resemble installment plans, albeit with notable differences. Installment loans typically involve borrowing a lump sum from a lender, which is then repaid in fixed amounts, or "installments," often every month.

Sometimes, payday lenders may offer installment repayment options, allowing borrowers to spread their payments over several months rather than requiring a lump sum payment on their next payday. This approach can give borrowers greater flexibility in managing repayment, potentially reducing the financial strain of a single-payment payday loan. In some cases, these loans are referred to as emergency loans instead of payday loans.

However, payday loans structured as installment plans may still carry high fees and interest rates, potentially resulting in substantial overall costs. Additionally, unlike traditional installment loans, where the account is typically closed once fully repaid, payday installment loans may tempt borrowers into a cycle of borrowing, as they can easily reapply for additional funds once the initial loan is paid off.

Some lenders may offer more structured repayment schedules for payday installment loans, providing borrowers with clear timelines and payment amounts. However, borrowers should carefully assess the terms and compare them to alternative lending options to ensure they make the best choice for their financial situation.

The Revolving Aspect of Payday Loans

Payday loans, subject to state regulation, have a unique revolving aspect that can trap borrowers in a cycle of debt. Traditionally, states capped small loan rates at 24 to 48% annual interest and mandated installment repayment schedules. However, in states where legislatures deregulated small loans or exempted payday loans from traditional regulations, triple-digit interest rates and full repayment on the next payday became legal.

Despite efforts by 18 states and the District of Columbia to prohibit high-cost payday lending through usury rate caps, many borrowers still find themselves drawn to these loans due to their accessibility, especially if they lack access to traditional, lower-interest loans. The allure of quick cash can outweigh the risks, especially for those with poor credit.

One factor contributing to the revolving nature of payday loans is the option to roll over or renew the loan. If borrowers cannot repay the loan in full by the due date, they may extend the loan term by paying additional fees. While this may provide temporary relief, it can lead to a cycle of borrowing and repayment, with fees accumulating each time the loan is renewed.

The combination of high interest rates, short repayment periods, and rollover options creates a precarious situation for borrowers, often resulting in long-term financial hardship. As such, it's a must for individuals to carefully consider their options and seek alternatives to payday loans whenever possible.

A couple meeting with a financial advisor discussing a loan

Common alternatives to a payday loan include:

  • Borrowing from Family or Friends: Consider reaching out to loved ones for a loan, which may come with more flexible terms and lower interest rates.
  • Seeking Assistance from Community Organizations: Many community-based organizations offer financial assistance or low-interest loan programs for those in need.
  • Exploring Credit Union Loans: Credit unions often provide small, short-term loans with more favorable terms compared to payday lenders.
  • Negotiating Payment Plans with Creditors: Contact creditors to discuss extended payment plans or hardship arrangements to manage existing debts.
  • Building Emergency Savings: Prioritize building an emergency fund to cover unexpected expenses, reducing the need for short-term loans in the future.

Pros and Cons of Each Structure

When payday loans operate as installment plans or revolving credit, each structure has its own advantages and drawbacks. Understanding these can help borrowers make informed decisions regarding their financial needs.

Installment Plan Pros

  • Predictable Payments: Fixed installment amounts make budgeting easier and provide clarity on repayment obligations.
  • Structured Repayment: Scheduled payments over a defined period offer a clear path to full loan repayment.
  • Potential Lower Overall Cost: By spreading payments over time, borrowers may incur lower total costs compared to lump-sum payday loans.

Installment Plan Cons

  • Rigid Terms: Fixed repayment schedules may not accommodate unexpected financial fluctuations or changes in income.
  • Risk of Default: Missing installment payments can lead to late fees and negatively impact credit scores.
  • Limited Flexibility: Once a loan is taken out, borrowers may be unable to access additional funds until the current loan is fully repaid.

Revolving Credit Pros

  • Flexibility in Borrowing: Borrowers can access funds as needed within a predetermined credit limit, providing financial flexibility.
  • Tailored Repayment: Minimum payment requirements offer flexibility in managing monthly cash flow.
  • Opportunity for Gradual Repayment: Borrowers can repay the balance gradually over time, potentially reducing immediate financial strain.

Revolving Credit Cons

  • High Overall Cost: High interest rates and fees can accumulate quickly, resulting in substantial long-term costs.
  • Risk of Debt Spiral: Easy access to funds may lead to overspending and a cycle of debt if not managed responsibly.
  • Credit Score Impact: Utilization of revolving credit can impact credit scores, particularly if balances are consistently high relative to credit limits.

Ultimately, borrowers should carefully weigh these factors and consider their individual financial circumstances when choosing between installment plans and revolving credit for payday loans.

Someone receiving cash for a short term loan

Responsible Borrowing Tips

When facing financial emergencies, understanding loan structures and borrowing responsibly are crucial. Here are ten responsible borrowing tips to help manage payday loan repayment and navigate financial emergency solutions:

  • Explore Alternatives: Consider alternatives, such as borrowing from family or friends, before applying for a loan.
  • Assess Need: Evaluate if the loan is truly necessary and if there are other ways to address the financial need.
  • Timely Payments: Make payments on time to avoid late fees and potential negative impacts on credit.
  • Meet Minimum Payments: Aim to pay at least the minimum amount due each month to keep interest under control.
  • Read the Fine Print: Thoroughly review the loan agreement, including terms and conditions, before signing.
  • Monitor Credit: Regularly check your credit report and work to improve your credit score for better loan access in the future.
  • Budgeting: Establish a family budget to ensure you can afford loan payments without sacrificing essential expenses.
  • Avoid Overborrowing: Borrow only what you need and ensure you have the means to make your payments to avoid falling into a cycle of debt.
  • Seek Financial Counseling: Consider seeking advice from financial counselors to explore long-term financial solutions.
  • Plan for Repayment: Develop and stick to a repayment plan, allocating funds specifically for monthly loan repayment.

Making Informed Financial Decisions

Understanding the nuances between installment and revolving payday loans is a non-negotiable in managing one's financial health. Throughout this blog, we've explored each loan structure's differences, advantages, and drawbacks. By grasping these distinctions, borrowers can make informed decisions when facing financial emergencies, avoiding potential pitfalls and managing repayment responsibly.

Whether considering alternative options, reading loan agreements carefully, or establishing a budget, responsible borrowing is key to navigating financial challenges effectively. We encourage readers to stay informed and explore resources like the Cash Store blog for further insights into managing finances wisely.

In times of urgent need, options like installment loans or cash advance loans may provide a lifeline. However, weighing the terms, understanding the repayment structure, and borrowing only what's necessary is essential. Individuals can pave the way toward a more stable financial future by prioritizing financial literacy and making informed choices.

The content on this page provides general consumer information or tips. It is not financial advice or guidance. Each person’s circumstances are unique. The Cash Store may update this information periodically. This information may also include links or references to third-party resources or content. We do not endorse the third-party or guarantee the accuracy of this third-party information. There may be other resources that also serve your needs.

More Articles

Gig Worker Guide - How to Get Started

Gig workers are becoming more common, as people find the benefits of flexible scheduling, earnings potential, and more. Learn more in our 2024 gig worker guide.

Read More >

How Can I Check My Credit Score Online?

Your credit score is essential to so many financial decisions and opportunities. Here’s how to check your credit score online with ease.

Read More >

Avoiding the Pitfalls: How to Use Short-Term Loans Responsibly

Short-term loans are an essential financial instrument for navigating financial challenges when used properly. Here’s how to use short-term loans responsibly.

Read More >

Trusted provider of cash loans since 1996


Connect With Us

Loan Amount is subject to loan approval. Loan terms and availability may vary by location.  Approval rate based on complete applications received across all Cash Store locations. Customers can typically expect to receive loan proceeds in less than 20 minutes; however, processing times may vary. Loans / Advances are provided based on approved credit. Each applicant for credit is evaluated for creditworthiness. Vehicle is subject to evaluation for title/auto equity loans.

Please see the Licenses and Rates page for additional product details.

Cash Store offers consumer credit products that are generally short-term in nature and not intended for long-term borrowing needs.

In Texas, Cash Store is a Credit Services Organization. Loans are provided by a non-affiliated third-party lender. Please see the Licenses and Rates page for links to Consumer Disclosures and choose the one for the product and amount that most closely relates to your loan request.

Customer Portal residency restrictions apply. Availability of funds may vary by financial institution.